Autor/es reacciones

Mikel Galar

Lecturer in the Department of Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence at the Public University of Navarra

This methodologically sound study examines gender biases in artificial intelligence models applied to recruitment processes. Its main contribution is to analyse how these biases can accumulate at different stages: first, when AI helps to generate a CV, and subsequently, when it is used to assess it. The results show that the models reproduce existing inequalities in the labour market, penalising women in male-dominated professions and favouring them in female-dominated ones (by around 3 per cent in each direction). As these two effects cancel each other out, on average the bias appears non-existent, demonstrating that relying on averages alone is insufficient when auditing these systems.

It is important to emphasise that the study demonstrates that the models reproduce gender biases and that these can accumulate, but not that their use increases discrimination compared with current recruitment processes. In fact, the pay gaps in the models’ recommendations (around 1.6 per cent) are smaller than those existing in the labour market, although the two figures are not directly comparable. Nor are there any simple solutions to avoid these biases: asking the model to be neutral changes nothing, and asking it to favour women results in overcorrection. Rather than proving that AI exacerbates workplace discrimination, the study identifies risks. The outstanding question is whether these systems discriminate more or less than the alternatives they replace.

EN