Autor/es reacciones

Patricia Sánchez-Holgado

Lecturer in the Department of Sociology and Communication at the University of Salamanca

This study is highly relevant in the context of the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the human resources and recruitment sector, particularly when examining gender inequalities in the labour market.

What is most interesting is that it presents an innovative approach, as it carries out an empirical analysis of the interaction between supply and demand – that is, job applications (AI-generated CVs) and the assessment of those applications using the same AI tools. It stands out because it does so on a large scale, as it evaluates, in a controlled environment (not in a real-world setting), six of the most advanced models (GPT 5.4, Claude Opus 4.6, DeepSeek 3.2, Mistral Large 3, Grok 4.1 and Llama 3.3 70B) across 98 real occupational categories from the US census, generating and evaluating over 35,000 CVs.

The key finding is that, as the same AI systems are used both to draft CVs and to assess them and recommend salaries, an algorithmic amplification occurs: the biases generated during CV drafting are subsequently reinforced when the AI assesses that same profile. In other words, it demonstrates that AI not only absorbs the stereotypes from its training data, but also amplifies them when used both to draft applications and to evaluate them. Along the same lines, with regard to gender, it is observed that AI does not penalise women uniformly, but rather replicates the segregation found in the real labour market. If only the applicant’s gender is changed, the models penalise women in male-dominated sectors and favour them in female-dominated sectors, including in relation to pay, meaning that gender pay gaps will persist.

The practical implications of this research are direct for companies, regulators and jobseekers. The automation of human resources does not guarantee objectivity, but rather carries a measurable risk of algorithmic amplification if the same systems filter the texts they previously helped to create. Statistical audits disaggregated by sector are necessary, as overall averages conceal the real inequalities.

EN