Alberto Ortiz Lobo
Doctor of Medicine and Psychiatrist at the Carlos III Day Hospital - La Paz University Hospital (Madrid)
Neuroscientific studies relating to psychiatric diagnoses seek to bridge the gap between clinical mental phenomena and their brain-based explanation. There can be no doubt as to the inevitability—not only of the brain or the central nervous system, but of the entire body—in shaping what we understand as subjectivity; yet it is worth asking whether the complexity of the human condition can be reduced to a product of the brain.
This research is based on two misleading methodological constructs: the standardisation of such a diverse and context-dependent experience as the human response to an adverse event under the label of ‘post-traumatic stress disorder’, and its reduction to molecular phenomena within the brain.
Given the purely correlational nature of the data, it cannot explain the significance of the results obtained or the role of the structures involved in the phenomena under investigation. This is a recurring feature in neuroscientific studies of psychiatric diagnoses: the widespread search for causal explanations conflicts with the correlational nature of the findings and leads to interpretative leaps from correlations to causes.
Ultimately, what is presented as promising research that takes the brain-based explanation of post-traumatic stress disorder for granted is irrelevant to clinical practice; its approach may prove naïve in its disregard for human complexity and context, and runs the risk of being counterproductive, by focusing on brain tissue (dead, to add to the irony) and definitively dismissing people’s unique accounts of their life stories, individual experiences and the specific impacts of adverse events on each of them.