Miguel Motas
Professor of Toxicology in the Department of Social and Health Sciences at the University of Murcia
Is the study based on solid data and methods?
‘The study is based on data obtained using a robust, reliable, consolidated and highly sensitive technique for analysing inorganic elements, namely ICP-MS. Although the methods have their limitations due to the difficulty of sampling, they are rigorous enough to guarantee the validity of the results obtained.’
What new information does it provide?
‘This is quite a novel study, as there is little literature on the presence of many of the elements studied in bananas. It also clarifies the influence of volcanic activity on the release of pollutants into the environment and, therefore, the possible contamination of the food chain and the risk to the population.’
Are there any important limitations to bear in mind?
‘The number of samples due to the difficulty of collection in areas exposed to the volcano and, as it is opportunistic sampling due to the volcanic eruption, there are factors that have not been taken into account that may influence the absorption and transport of elements such as soil type, topography and moisture content.’
What do these results mean in practice for consumers?
‘Although levels of elements increase after the eruption, the toxic risk from these elements after the eruption is minimal (estimated intake less than 1% of the tolerable daily intake) and does not pose any problem for the population, making bananas not only a safe but also a healthy option.’
What practical recommendations could we make based on this work?
‘It is very beneficial to eat bananas, especially for people with molybdenum and cobalt deficiencies, as bananas provide 37% and 21% of the recommended daily intake of these important elements, respectively.’