This article is 6 months old
Pedestrians are twice as likely to be hit by electric or hybrid cars as by petrol or diesel cars

According to a study on the number of pedestrian accidents in Great Britain between 2013 and 2017, published in the Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, the risk of pedestrian crashes was twice as high for electric and hybrid vehicles as for petrol and diesel vehicles.  

22/05/2024 - 00:30 CEST
Expert reactions

Kevin McConway - peatones coches eléctricos EN

Kevin McConway

Emeritus Professor of Applied Statistics, Open University

Science Media Centre UK

This is an interesting study but it does have limitations. Several are pointed out by the researchers in the research paper.

I think the most important limitation is that the results tell us that collision rates with pedestrians are higher with electric or hybrid cars than with cars with internal combustion engines, but the study can't tell us why the rates are higher. The researchers suggest that it could be because pedestrians can't hear the electric cars well, in urban settings. That's certainly a plausible possibility.

But there are other possibilities. If electric and hybrid cars are, on average, driven differently than other cars, perhaps because they are used for different purposes or have different types of driver, then that could be a reason for the different collision rates, rather than the actual type of propulsion or the sound it makes. The researchers mention that drivers of electric and hybrid cars tend to be younger, and that younger, inexperienced drivers tend to have more collisions, but that's not the only possible reason that's not directly to do with the car's engine type. This type of research can't distinguish between all these possibilities, and that's why further research would be needed.

Another possible issue is that the data used is quite old now, from 2013-17. The researchers point out that it's the latest available, but perhaps pedestrians and drivers have changed their behaviour as electric cars have become more common on the roads.

I am a Trustee of the SMC and a member of its Advisory Committee.  My quote above is in my capacity as an independent professional statistician.

EN
Publications
Pedestrian safety on the road to net zero: cross-sectional study of collisions with electric and hybrid-electric cars in Great Britain
  • Research article
  • Peer reviewed
  • People
Journal
Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health
Publication date
Authors

Phil J Edwards et al. 

Study types:
  • Research article
  • Peer reviewed
  • People
The 5Ws +1
Publish it
FAQ
Contact