This article is 7 months old
Reaction: Ukrainian refugees are perceived more positively by European citizens than Syrians or Somalis

Research carried out with almost 300 participants from the United Kingdom and Malta revealed that they had more positive emotions, a willingness to help and less prejudice towards Ukrainian asylum seekers compared to Syrian or Somali refugees. According to the author, whose study is published in PLOS ONE, this is explained because “the perceived threat and negative emotions led to greater prejudice, which in turn led to a lower predisposition toward help.”

13/09/2023 - 20:00 CEST
 
Expert reactions

Carmen González - refugiados Ucrania EN

Carmen González Enríquez

Professor of Political Science at UNED and principal researcher at the Elcano Royal Institute, where she directs the areas of Public Opinion and Migration

Science Media Centre Spain

The study reliably shows something that was implicit in the reaction of European societies towards the reception of Ukrainian refugees: the fact that these refugees are perceived by Europeans more favorably than those from other regions of the world.

Based on empirical research, a survey, developed in the United Kingdom and Malta, the analysis shows that the British and Maltese have more favorable feelings (less fear, more sympathy) towards Ukrainian refugees than towards Syrians and Somalis.

Surveys indicate that Spaniards have more positive attitudes towards receiving refugees than Britons or Maltese. However, there has never been such an intense spontaneous mobilization of aid to Syrian or Somali refugees in Spain as that which occurred in 2022 in favor of the Ukrainians, which suggests that also in our country the feelings aroused by some and others are different.

The most important limitation of the study is that it does not investigate the perception among Europeans of the war in Ukraine, compared to the perception of the causes that motivate departures from Syria or Somalia. And therefore, the study cannot identify a key element to understand the special response of European societies towards Ukrainian refugees: the fear of Western Europeans of Russian aggressiveness and expansionism, which threaten not only Ukraine but the entire Europe. Without remembering that Europe has been involved in that war in many ways – something that has not happened either in Syria or Somalia – the reaction of European societies and states to the Ukrainian refugees cannot be understood.

To suggest, as the study does, that they are better welcomed essentially because they are white and of Christian heritage is to forget the most important component: that we participate indirectly but undoubtedly in the war in favor of Ukrainian sovereignty and, therefore, these refugees. They are allies against a common enemy.

The author has not responded to our request to declare conflicts of interest
EN
Publications
Emotions, perceived threat, prejudice, and attitudes towards helping Ukrainian, Syrian, and Somali asylum seekers
  • Research article
  • Peer reviewed
  • People
Journal
PLoS ONE
Publication date
Authors

Sharon Xuereb.

Study types:
  • Research article
  • Peer reviewed
  • People
The 5Ws +1
Publish it
FAQ
Contact