Tatiana Íñiguez Berrozpe
The article in question is not a new study, but rather a review by an international group of experts of the available evidence on screen use and people’s wellbeing – particularly that of children – as a basis for proposing policy recommendations, a highly commendable aim. The document’s greatest strength, in my view, is its conceptualisation of the variables to be taken into account. That is to say, it moves away from simply counting hours of screen time and focuses instead on problematic internet use, and, in particular, on how products are designed: infinite scrolling, unpredictable rewards or personalised notifications. In other words, we finally have an expert analysis that shifts the focus from the individual’s willpower to the design decisions made by companies. In other words, from agency to structure – something we have been advocating ever since sociological research on the subject began. Furthermore, and this is also unusual, the authors honestly acknowledge that almost all the available studies are snapshots of a single moment – cross-sectional studies – and do not allow us to speak of causes; they therefore advocate a precautionary approach in the absence of certainty. This last point could be debatable, as the precautionary principle is a term primarily associated with healthcare and, in this case, could be used to fuel moral panic regarding the use of devices without clear and verified evidence.
One limitation of the studies analysed is the enormous variability in how problematic use is measured: with over thirty different questionnaires and varying thresholds, the same figure does not mean the same thing in two different countries. Added to this is the difficulty of separating the phenomenon of problematic device use from other issues with which it is associated: depression, anxiety or ADHD. Furthermore, paradoxically, the conclusion drawn from the text is that the problem is greater in low- and middle-income countries, yet much of the evidence used comes from wealthy countries.
Another contradiction in this type of study is that they argue that problematic internet use does not affect everyone equally (with a higher risk among young people, those with pre-existing mental health problems and in the most vulnerable contexts). However, virtually all the studies included in the document fail to take these variables – such as social class or vulnerability – into account in their analyses, which severely limits the interpretation of the causal relationship between problematic internet use and distress, when in many cases that distress stems from personal and social causes.
Furthermore, the document, despite its caution, states that the prevalence of PIU is ‘more than 10 per cent’, although this estimate is at the very high end of a range of findings that vary from 0.3 per cent to 40 per cent depending on the country and the questionnaire used. In fact, studies using better-designed instruments tend to yield lower figures.
Furthermore, the cost associated with problematic use is overestimated, as the report cites a figure of 10,000–12,000 million pounds; this is not an exact measurement, but rather an illustrative exercise based on analogies and assumptions.
For countries considering a ban on social media for under-16s, there are two particularly useful points to bear in mind.
The first is that the Commission drafting the report argues that age limits, on their own, are too crude a tool because they do not address the design features of the platforms that may lead to addiction, and it warns of the privacy and circumvention issues involved in age verification. The second, which is not often mentioned, is that imposing restrictions on access to social media may not reduce the symptoms and could even make them worse, because, at times, these platforms serve as an anchor for many young people, connecting them to a support network, whether real or virtual. This makes the most intuitive response at home and at school – banning mobile phones – inadvisable, and instead points towards guidance, early digital literacy and addressing what a teenager stops doing when they spend many hours online.
And an important clarification to avoid scaremongering: the document itself points out that the internet is not harmful in itself. Therefore, the aim is not to reduce internet use, but to call on technology companies to design their platforms more responsibly.