A commission is calling for problematic internet use to be recognised as a global health issue and for the design of platforms to be regulated
A report drawn up by an international commission, which included Spanish participation, states that governments should recognise problematic internet use as a global public health issue and regulate the design features that keep people online, such as infinite scrolling and autoplay. The commission, whose report is published in the journal The Lancet Psychiatry, states that, despite the gaps, the current evidence base is sufficient to justify regulatory action at national and international level.
José Perales - Comision PUI
José César Perales
Professor in the department of Experimental Psychology at the University of Granada
Firstly, it is important to note that this article is not an empirical study, but rather a document resulting from the deliberations of the Lancet Psychiatry Commission on Global Action on Problematic Use of the Internet, that is, the group of experts commissioned by the journal The Lancet Psychiatry to establish a position on the need to conceptualise and address problematic internet use (PUI) globally from a public health perspective.
Although well-intentioned, this document does not follow standardised recommendations to ensure that the selection of experts is sufficiently representative of existing geographical or theoretical diversity; consequently, its value rests on the authority of the individuals comprising the commission. To an observer familiar with the field, it is evident that some of the most prominent researchers in the field—and particularly those who might offer a more critical or sceptical perspective on the position set out in the article—are not part of the committee. In other words, the committee is, in many respects, excessively homogeneous.
Beyond the identity of its members, the literature review provided is far from systematic; as a result, it presents a selective overview of the evidence supporting the positions described in the text, whilst omitting evidence that does not support them.
These criticisms can be summarised as follows:
- The internet is not a behaviour or an activity, but an extremely vast and diverse ecosystem in which countless different behaviours take place. Speaking of ‘problematic internet use’ is conceptually similar to speaking of ‘problematic use of the urban environment’, which would clearly sound ridiculous. It should be noted that when referring to subtypes of problematic internet use currently recognised in diagnostic systems (gambling disorder, compulsive online pornography use and video game use disorder), one is in fact referring to behaviours that may be pathological regardless of whether they occur online or offline. In other words, creating a generic category for the internet may, in fact, dilute forms of pathological behaviour that are so not because of the environment in which they occur, but because of the very nature of those behaviours and the impact they have on people’s quality of life. Indirectly, this may lead to the trivialisation of these problems, as they are perceived as analogous to others whose actual severity is much lower.
- The idea is assumed from the outset that problematic internet use can be addressed using the addiction model, with the unsubstantiated claim that there is extensive evidence and widespread agreement on the suitability of this model. Whilst this may be true for, for example, gambling disorder (regardless of whether it takes place online or offline), there is far from a consensus – not even a majority one – regarding other activities such as the use of social media or watching streaming channels. Many authors in the field have put forward alternative theoretical models that go a long way towards explaining why certain online activities can become problematic without conceptualising them as addictive. On this point, too, it is uncritically assumed that the ‘dark patterns’ present in some digital applications can be defined as addictive simply because they make it difficult for users to exercise effective control. Autoplay or infinite scrolling are cited as examples of such ‘dark patterns’, but the available evidence does not allow us to conclude that the reasons why these features may facilitate excessive or immersive use are even similar to the reasons why drugs of abuse are addictive. There is a clear over-interpretation of the available biological evidence to support this parallel. This is not to say that these features are not potentially harmful to some people, but defining them as addictive implies a significant conceptual confusion. In this regard, and in line with the points made above, it is important to note that a considerable number of the authors who have produced this report come from a research tradition that advocates a theoretical approach closely aligned with the broad application of the addiction model to a whole range of behaviours that do not involve substance use. To a certain extent, their theoretical stance carries a risk of bias when assessing and presenting the evidence.
- Finally, when formulating public health recommendations, the authors advocate a restrictive interpretation of the precautionary principle, similar to that previously applied to other potential sources of harm such as alcohol, tobacco or gambling. However, there are differing philosophical and political viewpoints on just how strict or restrictive the application of the precautionary principle should be, depending on the nature of the risk. It is clear that alcohol, tobacco and gambling are harmful in small or moderate doses and, more importantly, restricting their use does not severely affect individual rights and freedoms. However, as recognised in the document, internet use involves risks, but also constructive, healthy and even necessary possibilities. And not only that: restricting access to certain digital applications or platforms may adversely affect freedom of expression and communication, as well as holistic development and access to information. The potential risks stem not only from the activity itself, but also from the measures that may be taken to combat them, however well-intentioned they may be. An example of this can be found in the recent Australian case, where the ban on access to social media for under-16s not only appears to be failing to have the desired effects, but may also be causing unintended consequences for a not insignificant proportion of the people it was intended to protect.
In summary, whilst I recognise the document’s good intentions and the need to address the risks present in the digital environment on the basis of evidence, I have more than reasonable doubts as to whether the approach taken is appropriate or whether it represents the majority view amongst experts in the field. On the one hand, because the term ‘PUI’ is far too generic to capture the multifaceted nature of the potentially problematic behaviours that can occur online; and, on the other, because prioritising the addiction model over other alternatives more faithful to the evidence imposes an extremely narrow theoretical lens through which to understand and address the potential harms arising from such behaviours.
Tatiana Íñiguez - Comision PUI
Tatiana Íñiguez Berrozpe
The article in question is not a new study, but rather a review by an international group of experts of the available evidence on screen use and people’s wellbeing – particularly that of children – as a basis for proposing policy recommendations, a highly commendable aim. The document’s greatest strength, in my view, is its conceptualisation of the variables to be taken into account. That is to say, it moves away from simply counting hours of screen time and focuses instead on problematic internet use, and, in particular, on how products are designed: infinite scrolling, unpredictable rewards or personalised notifications. In other words, we finally have an expert analysis that shifts the focus from the individual’s willpower to the design decisions made by companies. In other words, from agency to structure – something we have been advocating ever since sociological research on the subject began. Furthermore, and this is also unusual, the authors honestly acknowledge that almost all the available studies are snapshots of a single moment – cross-sectional studies – and do not allow us to speak of causes; they therefore advocate a precautionary approach in the absence of certainty. This last point could be debatable, as the precautionary principle is a term primarily associated with healthcare and, in this case, could be used to fuel moral panic regarding the use of devices without clear and verified evidence.
One limitation of the studies analysed is the enormous variability in how problematic use is measured: with over thirty different questionnaires and varying thresholds, the same figure does not mean the same thing in two different countries. Added to this is the difficulty of separating the phenomenon of problematic device use from other issues with which it is associated: depression, anxiety or ADHD. Furthermore, paradoxically, the conclusion drawn from the text is that the problem is greater in low- and middle-income countries, yet much of the evidence used comes from wealthy countries.
Another contradiction in this type of study is that they argue that problematic internet use does not affect everyone equally (with a higher risk among young people, those with pre-existing mental health problems and in the most vulnerable contexts). However, virtually all the studies included in the document fail to take these variables – such as social class or vulnerability – into account in their analyses, which severely limits the interpretation of the causal relationship between problematic internet use and distress, when in many cases that distress stems from personal and social causes.
Furthermore, the document, despite its caution, states that the prevalence of PIU is ‘more than 10 per cent’, although this estimate is at the very high end of a range of findings that vary from 0.3 per cent to 40 per cent depending on the country and the questionnaire used. In fact, studies using better-designed instruments tend to yield lower figures.
Furthermore, the cost associated with problematic use is overestimated, as the report cites a figure of 10,000–12,000 million pounds; this is not an exact measurement, but rather an illustrative exercise based on analogies and assumptions.
For countries considering a ban on social media for under-16s, there are two particularly useful points to bear in mind.
The first is that the Commission drafting the report argues that age limits, on their own, are too crude a tool because they do not address the design features of the platforms that may lead to addiction, and it warns of the privacy and circumvention issues involved in age verification. The second, which is not often mentioned, is that imposing restrictions on access to social media may not reduce the symptoms and could even make them worse, because, at times, these platforms serve as an anchor for many young people, connecting them to a support network, whether real or virtual. This makes the most intuitive response at home and at school – banning mobile phones – inadvisable, and instead points towards guidance, early digital literacy and addressing what a teenager stops doing when they spend many hours online.
And an important clarification to avoid scaremongering: the document itself points out that the internet is not harmful in itself. Therefore, the aim is not to reduce internet use, but to call on technology companies to design their platforms more responsibly.
Natalia Martín - Comision PUI
Natalia Martín-María
Assistant Professor in the Department of Biological and Health Psychology at the Faculty of Psychology UAM
Problematic internet use (UPI or PUI) is a broad term used to refer to various negative ways of interacting with the internet and digital technology. It poses a global public health challenge and entails high social costs. Recent meta-analyses suggest that this harmful use could affect more than one in ten people worldwide.
The Lancet Psychiatry Commission on Global Action on PUI has conducted this review of the literature to identify the related concepts (where they appear, for example, compulsive online shopping disorder, cyberchondria as an analogue of hypochondria, or compulsive online sexual behaviour—which includes problematic pornography use—), their prevalence, the associated psychosocial factors, costs and burden, what interventions and regulations currently exist, and, finally, what future courses of action are recommended.
The conclusions regarding its management are particularly relevant, with digital literacy for both children and their families, restrictions on access, and physical exercise emerging as effective measures. The prevention of IUP is particularly important for children and young people, especially those who exhibit the risk factors identified in the review, such as low satisfaction with physical appearance, poor emotional regulation, or conflicts within the family or with peers.
Globally, there are many shortcomings in services and regulatory policies relating to UPI. Immediate actions—such as eliminating infinite scrolling or autoplay—coordinated at both national and international levels are necessary to mitigate the harm associated with UPI.
Ignacio Morgado - Comision PUI
Ignacio Morgado
Professor Emeritus of Psychobiology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona (UAB) and full member of the Spanish Academy of Psychology
An excellent and comprehensive review of the dangers – particularly for young people and those who are not yet emotionally mature – of overexposure to the internet, with particular attention paid to users’ mental health.
Excessive addiction, compulsive behaviour involving social media use or unnecessary shopping, and other behavioural disorders – as well as possible associated comorbidity – now plague those who make inappropriate and uncontrolled use of new digital technologies, including artificial intelligence.
The phenomenon is particularly worrying because it affects more than 10 per cent of the world’s population.
A distinguished group of signatories to the report, with the collaboration and support of professionals from numerous countries around the world, including Spain, highlights the health and economic risks posed by digital technologies and warns of the need to establish public policies on prevention and regulation to avert these risks and their significant and unstoppable spread.
This is an extraordinary piece of work by The Lancet’s Psychiatry Commission, which should be brought to the attention of all those involved in planning for citizens’ physical and mental health, whether in the political sphere or in educational institutions.
Josep Maria Suelves - uso problemático internet
Josep Maria Suelves
Researcher at the Behavioural Design Lab at the UOC eHealth Centre, member of the board of directors of the Public Health Society of Catalonia and the Balearic Islands, and vice-chairman of the National Committee for the Prevention of Smoking
The article just published in Lancet Psychiatry presents the work of a committee comprising experts in the fields of mental health and addiction, who have summarised and commented on the evidence relating to the concept of problematic internet use, its prevalence and impact, interventions for its prevention and treatment, and the proposed regulatory frameworks to address it.
The term ‘problematic internet use’ is used to refer to an excessively broad and heterogeneous spectrum of adverse situations related to the use of the internet and digital technologies, which includes both potential problems arising from prolonged exposure to digital devices (lack of rest, a sedentary lifestyle, interference with personal relationships…) as well as the development of mental health disorders and the exacerbation of pre-existing conditions (pathological gambling, suicidal behaviour, affective disorders, addictions…), right through to the risks arising from exposure to certain content (pornography, fake news, advertising of products and services harmful to health, inappropriate aesthetic and behavioural models…). Children and certain groups of people — such as those suffering from addictions and other mental health conditions — are particularly vulnerable to developing problems related to the use of the internet and other digital technologies.
The activities of economic actors, such as large industrial and technology corporations, seek to maximise their profits without taking into account their impact on people’s health and well-being. The influence of business activity on health—the commercial determinants of health—has a significant impact on public health in sectors such as tobacco, the automotive industry, non-renewable energy, and the food industry. In the case of the internet and digital technologies, companies’ financial profit often depends on the amount of time users spend using their products, which leads to the use of behavioural design strategies that pose significant risks, such as the use of algorithms that tailor incentives and rewards to the individual, and techniques such as infinite scrolling, etc.
The committee that drafted this article highlights the importance of establishing control measures that are proportionate, scientifically grounded, ethical and do not rely exclusively on the responsibility of digital technology users. Among the control policies reviewed to reduce the potential harms of the internet are age verification, automated systems that limit online time, parental controls on minors’ access, restrictions on the advertising of certain products and services such as online gambling or tobacco, awareness-raising programmes and campaigns aimed at the general public and, of course, the requirement for transparency and oversight of the algorithms that enable the personalisation of content targeted at users.
Fineberg et al.
- Peer reviewed
- Report