Autor/es reacciones

José César Perales

Professor in the department of Experimental Psychology at the University of Granada

Firstly, it is important to note that this article is not an empirical study, but rather a document resulting from the deliberations of the Lancet Psychiatry Commission on Global Action on Problematic Use of the Internet, that is, the group of experts commissioned by the journal The Lancet Psychiatry to establish a position on the need to conceptualise and address problematic internet use (PUI) globally from a public health perspective.

Although well-intentioned, this document does not follow standardised recommendations to ensure that the selection of experts is sufficiently representative of existing geographical or theoretical diversity; consequently, its value rests on the authority of the individuals comprising the commission. To an observer familiar with the field, it is evident that some of the most prominent researchers in the field—and particularly those who might offer a more critical or sceptical perspective on the position set out in the article—are not part of the committee. In other words, the committee is, in many respects, excessively homogeneous.

Beyond the identity of its members, the literature review provided is far from systematic; as a result, it presents a selective overview of the evidence supporting the positions described in the text, whilst omitting evidence that does not support them.

These criticisms can be summarised as follows:

  1. The internet is not a behaviour or an activity, but an extremely vast and diverse ecosystem in which countless different behaviours take place. Speaking of ‘problematic internet use’ is conceptually similar to speaking of ‘problematic use of the urban environment’, which would clearly sound ridiculous. It should be noted that when referring to subtypes of problematic internet use currently recognised in diagnostic systems (gambling disorder, compulsive online pornography use and video game use disorder), one is in fact referring to behaviours that may be pathological regardless of whether they occur online or offline. In other words, creating a generic category for the internet may, in fact, dilute forms of pathological behaviour that are so not because of the environment in which they occur, but because of the very nature of those behaviours and the impact they have on people’s quality of life. Indirectly, this may lead to the trivialisation of these problems, as they are perceived as analogous to others whose actual severity is much lower.
  2. The idea is assumed from the outset that problematic internet use can be addressed using the addiction model, with the unsubstantiated claim that there is extensive evidence and widespread agreement on the suitability of this model. Whilst this may be true for, for example, gambling disorder (regardless of whether it takes place online or offline), there is far from a consensus – not even a majority one – regarding other activities such as the use of social media or watching streaming channels. Many authors in the field have put forward alternative theoretical models that go a long way towards explaining why certain online activities can become problematic without conceptualising them as addictive. On this point, too, it is uncritically assumed that the ‘dark patterns’ present in some digital applications can be defined as addictive simply because they make it difficult for users to exercise effective control. Autoplay or infinite scrolling are cited as examples of such ‘dark patterns’, but the available evidence does not allow us to conclude that the reasons why these features may facilitate excessive or immersive use are even similar to the reasons why drugs of abuse are addictive. There is a clear over-interpretation of the available biological evidence to support this parallel. This is not to say that these features are not potentially harmful to some people, but defining them as addictive implies a significant conceptual confusion. In this regard, and in line with the points made above, it is important to note that a considerable number of the authors who have produced this report come from a research tradition that advocates a theoretical approach closely aligned with the broad application of the addiction model to a whole range of behaviours that do not involve substance use. To a certain extent, their theoretical stance carries a risk of bias when assessing and presenting the evidence.
  3. Finally, when formulating public health recommendations, the authors advocate a restrictive interpretation of the precautionary principle, similar to that previously applied to other potential sources of harm such as alcohol, tobacco or gambling. However, there are differing philosophical and political viewpoints on just how strict or restrictive the application of the precautionary principle should be, depending on the nature of the risk. It is clear that alcohol, tobacco and gambling are harmful in small or moderate doses and, more importantly, restricting their use does not severely affect individual rights and freedoms. However, as recognised in the document, internet use involves risks, but also constructive, healthy and even necessary possibilities. And not only that: restricting access to certain digital applications or platforms may adversely affect freedom of expression and communication, as well as holistic development and access to information. The potential risks stem not only from the activity itself, but also from the measures that may be taken to combat them, however well-intentioned they may be. An example of this can be found in the recent Australian case, where the ban on access to social media for under-16s not only appears to be failing to have the desired effects, but may also be causing unintended consequences for a not insignificant proportion of the people it was intended to protect.

In summary, whilst I recognise the document’s good intentions and the need to address the risks present in the digital environment on the basis of evidence, I have more than reasonable doubts as to whether the approach taken is appropriate or whether it represents the majority view amongst experts in the field. On the one hand, because the term ‘PUI’ is far too generic to capture the multifaceted nature of the potentially problematic behaviours that can occur online; and, on the other, because prioritising the addiction model over other alternatives more faithful to the evidence imposes an extremely narrow theoretical lens through which to understand and address the potential harms arising from such behaviours.

EN